Peer Review Policy

Peer Review Model

Peer Review Timeline

Peer Review Costs and Fees

Peer Review Model

All submissions to the Journal of Music Theory Pedagogy undergo initial review by the editors. Submissions that pass initial editorial screening will be peer reviewed by two to three anonymous readers. The Journal of Music Theory Pedagogy employs a double anonymous peer review model, in which peer reviewers will not be aware of the submitting authors' identity. In the case of a split decision, the editorial staff will be included for feedback and discussion. 

Peer Review Timeline

Manuscript submissions will be acknowledged via email upon receipt.

The editorial board sets a goal for decision within 6 weeks (42 days). Authors should keep a copy of the manuscript to prevent unforeseen software malfunction.

When revisions are requested, reviewers will outline the key issues to be resolved in the revised version. The author may decline to resubmit their manuscript or resubmit with changes. Upon resubmission, authors must provide a detailed list of changes made in response to reviewer feedback. If authors decline reviewer suggestions, they should provide a rationale.

A proof copy will be sent back to the authors prior to publication. This will allow the individuals to review copy-editing decisions prior to final publication.

Peer Review Costs and Fees

The Journal of Music Theory Pedagogy does not charge any review fees.